
The CMF “common area” has considerable acreage throughout the community boundaries.
While the majority of the common areas follow the roads throughout the community and require
lawn mowing, shrub and tree maintenance to support the “right of way” travel on paved streets,
gravel roads and the walking/horse trails there are structures to be maintained in attractive,
functional operation. The front entrance gate, garden area, the package delivery hut, and the
lighting in the entranceway off Cane Creek Road are the most obvious assets which require
ongoing maintenance. Also included in this category would be the map and lighting at the top of
the main entrance hill on Chestnut Mountain Parkway, the community dumpster and the soon to
be buried water tank.
The two structures which were built on common are parcels, the Pavilion and the “Barn” are
deep within the community and receive relatively little use. In terms of common area
maintenance, the “Barn” has the highest maintenance cost. Electricity, pest control, grass
mowing are regular activities which together are still modest and approximately $1,500 to
$2,000 in costs annually. Every few years, there is a larger expense of several thousand dollars
when the exterior needs to be re-stained or there is work on the doors or concrete that is
necessary.
Options for the “Barn.”
Many of the property owners have heard the background that the original owners built the Barn
as a potential community asset, but the facility constructed was not designed for practical use
and without bathroom and kitchen facilities, it has been unused except for annual HOA
meetings and even then, we have had to rent the tables, chairs and temporary restroom
facilities for the 3 to 4 hour period for the gathering.
Located in a “common area,” there are no property taxes on the facility, but also in view of this
location, it cannot be sold without extensive legal steps at the County level and changes in the
CMF HOA Bylaws and Restrictive Covenants. As a facility for inhabitation, will be many physical
modifications necessary.
Assumptions and Previous Research Shared with the HOA Owners in the 2018 and 2019
annual meetings.
1. There was little support for converting the barn to a facility that would involve a
commercial activity bringing guests into the community, e.g., an “Event Center” which
would be available for rental for weddings, parties, retreats, etc.
2. There was modest interest in an upfit to provide HOA Owners with an opportunity to use
it as a meeting center or even as an apartment for owners to use before or while building
their homes on lots within CMF.
3. In both of the above reconfiguring of the Barn facility, we reached out to local builders
who came on site and provided estimates which were between $150,000 to $260,000 for
the construction cost which did not include the furniture and some appliances or devices.
A half decade or more has passed since that research was accomplished and share with the
HOA Owners. As we approve our 2025 CMF HOA Budget for Operations and Capital projects,
the agenda for our annual 2024 meeting includes an open discussion. The last time the HOA
membership discussed potential options was over five (5) years ago. This is an opportunity to
discuss the current condition of the facility and grounds and to see if there are any factors in an
assessment of options which are new or have changed since the last discussion.
No action is necessary. But the future of the CMF Common Areas as an asset will continue to
include the Barn structure and adjacent grounds. The Board is seeking comments and
suggestions for the Barn facility, and the common area where it is maintained. As suggestions,
what options might we consider as a community?
1. Continue the status quo. The motivation would be that conditions in the future regarding
the active population within the community, might identify usage not previously
considered.
2. Disassemble the Barn facility and sell off the material, returning the site to a more
natural state. The concrete slab and patio areas would be a significant cost effort which
would wipe out much if not all of the “sale” of the above ground lumber and stonework.
3. Pursue and update the design and costs associated with making modest investments
(Bathrooms and septic system and a small kitchen) which would facilitate usage by CMF
owners for family gatherings or for the HOA meetings and modest social activities. This
would still be a capital investment of minimally between $50,000 and $75,000.
4. Reconsider and re-estimate the idea of conversion to apartment(s) for buyers who do
not have a home built on their property. We would expect this to cost at 2026 prices,
considerably more than the 2018-2019 estimate.
5. In addition to adding a bathroom and shower along with the septic system, for the benefit
of CMF Owners who do not yet have a home constructed, would we consider including
RV Hook-up infrastructure so that they could stay in an RV when visiting CMF and their
property.
6. Consider the Barn facility and protected area surrounding the Barn for Property Owner
only space rental for equipment. This could be bare bones, no frills, with a rental fee or
it could be done with linkage in partnership to some or all improvements in point #5.
7. Other Ideas to consider?
There is no immediate crisis that dictates that some action is necessary. The Board has
approved additional maintenance (Concrete floor extensions for risk prevention and
maintenance simplification.
The discussion at the annual meeting is for feedback and input. If no suggestions on a longer
term strategy receive a reasonable level of support to further research, the minutes will reflect
that the status quo remains.
Suggested Option for the barn.
The barn with the current improvement of concreting the stalls has given us a meeting place in doors and eliminates the outlay for tent rentals. The HOA has also purchased our own tables and chairs, eliminating another rental expense. Currently the barn presents us with an annual expense, (per the 2023 financial year) as follows.
Insurance $4,074.00
Maintenance $2,928.60
Annual Meeting Expense $2,418.96
5 Year log refinishing $1,000.00
Annual Total $10,418.96
Concrete, Table & Chairs expense eliminated $2,000.00
Effective 2025 Annual Expense $8,418.98
This option is for use by HOA Members ONLY. Hold Harmless Agreements.
2025
Using 4 stall spaces as Storage Rentals
4 x $40 X12 months $1,920.00
5 RV Storage Spaces
5 X $65 X 12 months $3,900.00
2026
3 RV Full Facilites Service Hookups.
3 x $65 per day x 9 days x 12 Months $21,060.00
Total Revenue Potential by 2027 $26,880.00
Provides cash Flow of $18,461.02
Assuming a Capital Expense $60,000.00
ROI In 3 years.
(No assumptions on rate increases)